Returns & Exchanges

Extra Butter offers a 14-day return window for unworn, premium footwear and apparel in original packaging. Please note that certain high-heat releases and final sale items are ineligible for return or exchange.

Return Process

  • 1.
    Initiate Your Request

    Visit our online returns portal with your order number and zip code to select the items you wish to send back.

  • 2.
    Prepare the Package

    Securely pack the items in their original boxes, ensuring all tags are attached and the product is in its original condition.

  • 3.
    Ship the Items

    Affix the prepaid shipping label provided through the portal and drop off the package at any authorized carrier location.

  • 4.
    Receive Your Refund

    Once our warehouse inspects and approves the return, your refund will be processed back to your original payment method within 5-7 business days.